Wesley, Cordelia and Gunn return from a mission of destroying evil and discuss the demons they just destroyed and their "obsession" with demons and destroyimng them.

Fred, who has been mostly hiding in her room for about three months remains there, but listens to their conversation echoing around the hotel. They discuss Fred's reasons for staying separated and go on about Angel's mourning time at a monastery in Sri Lanka.

In Sri Lanka, Angel's mourning, however, is anything but peaceful as the monks turn out to be demons and Angel as a demon killer has to kill them all, much to the consternation of the local populace.

Angel returns to L.A. and and is welcomed home by his friends. After some 'subtle' hinting form Cordy, he gives them all unique gifts then goes upstairs to check on Fred. She's still very quiet and secluded, so Angel tries to pull Fred out of her shell and invites her downstairs, but a scream from Cordelia shatters her sense of safety.

A violent vision sends the guys after a party crashed by vampires, leaving Cordy to try to recover from the increasingly violent prescient images. They're too late to prevent the massacre, but while Wesley and Gunn call for help for the living, Angel rushes off after the vamps.

Several males and one female vampire have taken two hostages from the party. Angel prevents their escape, draws the vampires out of the car and tells their captives to escape while they still can.

The male vamp gets away, while the female is caught and staked by Angel. At the last minute, Angel and Elisabeth recognize each other and Elisabeth's locket falls off onto his hand as she turns to dust. Meanwhile, Cordelia recovers from the vision with the help of Dennis, a loofah, a relaxing bath and some powerful painkillers.

In the Evil-Angel past, Darla and Angelus roamed with Elisabeth and her love, James. Angelus is annoyed with the loving relationship between the other couple and concerned with escaping the vampire hunter, Holtz. Angelus remembers his last encounter with Holtz and James steals a locket from a store window for Elisabeth, (the locket Angel now has in his possession). Darla and Elisabeth are rushed off to their escape by ship while James and Angelus stand against Holtz.

Angel tells this story to his co-workers while looking over the locket in his hands. James and the vampire who escaped from Angel earlier, watch as the car is towed and Elisabeth's death becomes reality. James discovers who was responsible for taking her, then kills the cowardly vampire who left her alone.

Cordelia tries to get Angel to talk about the loss of Buffy, but he's not interested in the conversation. Although he won't continue the discussion about Buffy, she wants to know the rest of the story with Holtz.

Angelus taunts Holtz with comments in reference to how he and Darla killed the man's entire family. He offers Holtz James and Elisabeth, but James is far from pleased with that and attacks Angelus himself. Holtz's men shoot Angelus with several arrows before the two vampires ride off on a horse. James knocks Angelus off the horse and leaves him for the women waiting at the docks.

In the present, James charges into the office of a special doctor, demanding the ultimate cure. The doctor questions James's ability to accept the consequences, but an agreement is reached. At Caritas, the Host sings while Wesley and Gunn grill Merl for information. Gunn notifies Angel that James is in town and wants revenge.

At the hotel, Angel orders Cordelia to go home while it's still safe as he searches for the weapon he wants. Just as Angel goes to search the basement, James reveals himself from the underground area, attacking Angel. The vampires fight and James asks why Angel would take Elisabeth from him. The two fight and Cordelia manages a good hit to James with a fire extinguisher then tries to throw a stake to Angel, but James intercepts.

Merl and the Host give Wesley and Gunn the necessary information about James and Dr. Gregson who James went to visit earlier. Angel manages to stake James, who was made invicinble by having his heart removed. Angel and Cordelia run for the sewers and Angel throws James off temporarily with the scene of his blood. A call from Wesley vaguely reveals that James is now invincible, but it's not permanent and he will die when it wears off. James eventually catches on and chases Angel and Cordy into a subway train.

As they fight inside the train, James questions Angel's knowledge of true love. Angel assures him he understands it perfectly fine and knows what it's like to lose someone he loves. Soon, the effects of the cure ware off and James becomes dust with a few final words to Angel about love. At the hotel, Fred is likely to stay in her room for a while longer after additional trauma and discouragement. Angel allows James's comments about not being able to exist after losing the person he loved to get to him. Cordelia convinces him that he's only honoring Buffy by going on, not betraying her.

In Puerto Cabazas, Nicaragua, a man presents a card in reference to a Shaman to a woman and apologizes for the delay. The woman, Darla, is not interested in anything further from the man and quickly turns to sink her teeth into him. As he falls to the floor and she follows her drink with a slice of lime, Darla leaves the bar, revealing her heavily pregnant form.